HeaderIcon
  1. Agent Logo

Explore by Metro

  • Atlanta
  • Baltimore
  • Boston
  • Bronx
  • Brooklyn
  • Chicago
  • Los Angeles
  • Manhattan
  • Miami
  • Nashville
  • Orlando
  • Philadelphia
  • Phoenix
  • Queens
  • San Diego
  • San Jose
  • Tampa
  • Washington
HeaderIcon

Explore by Metro

  • Atlanta
  • Baltimore
  • Boston
  • Bronx
  • Brooklyn
  • Chicago
  • Los Angeles
  • Manhattan
  • Miami
  • Nashville
  • Orlando
  • Philadelphia
  • Phoenix
  • Queens
  • San Diego
  • San Jose
  • Tampa
  • Washington
leftArrowBack to Search
  1. Home
  2. /
  3. Evanston, IL
  4. /
  5. 2539.5 Prairie Avenue
Add to favoritesAdd to favorites (hover)
Save
leftArrow
Add to favoritesAdd to favorites (hover)

2539.5 Prairie Avenue

2539.5 Prairie Avenue, Evanston, IL, 60201

YEAR BUILT

1920

# STORIES

3

# TOTAL UNITS

8

UNIT SIZE RANGE

600-700 sqft

Description

The building located at 2539.5 Prairie Avenue sits in Evanston. This low-rise structure has 3 stories and 8 units. Built in 1920, it shows charm with its age while providing a cozy living environment. Each unit has 1 bedroom and ranges in size from 600 to 700 square feet. The prices for these units are between $190,850 and $200,500. This means the average price per square foot sits around $285. Units have been listed for a reasonable time, with the average days on market being 84. This timeframe gives buyers a good chance to explore their options, making it a nice opportunity for those looking to move. Nearby, residents can find Bluestone and Homemade Pizza Co. Local schools like the Evanston Arts Center are also just a short walk away. These businesses add to the community feel, making it easy for residents to engage with their neighborhood. A bike room and access to bike trails are great amenities. They encourage outdoor activities and a healthy lifestyle. Living here means embracing an active routine while enjoying the comforts of home. Being near the water adds to the charm as well. The location is close to several paths that lead to recreational areas. This access to nature is perfect for those who enjoy outdoor leisure activities.

Building ImageMLS ID #12082694
Building ImageMLS ID #12063801
Building Image
Building ImageView Listing

2539.5 Prairie Avenue

2539.5 Prairie Avenue, Evanston, IL, 60201

YEAR BUILT

1920

# STORIES

3

# TOTAL UNITS

8

UNIT SIZE RANGE

600-700 sqft

Description

The building located at 2539.5 Prairie Avenue sits in Evanston. This low-rise structure has 3 stories and 8 units. Built in 1920, it shows charm with its age while providing a cozy living environment. Each unit has 1 bedroom and ranges in size from 600 to 700 square feet. The prices for these units are between $190,850 and $200,500. This means the average price per square foot sits around $285. Units have been listed for a reasonable time, with the average days on market being 84. This timeframe gives buyers a good chance to explore their options, making it a nice opportunity for those looking to move. Nearby, residents can find Bluestone and Homemade Pizza Co. Local schools like the Evanston Arts Center are also just a short walk away. These businesses add to the community feel, making it easy for residents to engage with their neighborhood. A bike room and access to bike trails are great amenities. They encourage outdoor activities and a healthy lifestyle. Living here means embracing an active routine while enjoying the comforts of home. Being near the water adds to the charm as well. The location is close to several paths that lead to recreational areas. This access to nature is perfect for those who enjoy outdoor leisure activities.

Next

Description

The building located at 2539.5 Prairie Avenue sits in Evanston. This low-rise structure has 3 stories and 8 units. Built in 1920, it shows charm with its age while providing a cozy living environment. Each unit has 1 bedroom and ranges in size from 600 to 700 square feet. The prices for these units are between $190,850 and $200,500. This means the average price per square foot sits around $285. Units have been listed for a reasonable time, with the average days on market being 84. This timeframe gives buyers a good chance to explore their options, making it a nice opportunity for those looking to move. Nearby, residents can find Bluestone and Homemade Pizza Co. Local schools like the Evanston Arts Center are also just a short walk away. These businesses add to the community feel, making it easy for residents to engage with their neighborhood. A bike room and access to bike trails are great amenities. They encourage outdoor activities and a healthy lifestyle. Living here means embracing an active routine while enjoying the comforts of home. Being near the water adds to the charm as well. The location is close to several paths that lead to recreational areas. This access to nature is perfect for those who enjoy outdoor leisure activities.

2539.5 Prairie Avenue Key Stats Last 12 months

Avg. Listed Price$210,000($248/Sqft.)
Avg. Sale Price-
Year over year list priceUp Arrow5.00%
Year over year sale price 0.00%
Total Listings1 Listed
Total sold0 Sold
Average Days on Market0 days
Average HOA fees per sqft-
Next

Key Stats

Year over year list priceUp Arrow5.00%
Year over year sale price0.00%
Total Listings1 Listed
Total sold0 Sold
Average Days on Market0 days
Average HOA fees per sqft-

Glen Gardens Estate Availability & Demand

Unit Availability

Low
High availability buildings list units frequently.

Unit Availability helps to understand how often units in a particular building are listed for sale as compared with the neighborhood average. Units are rarely listed in buildings with low availability.

Unit Demand

Low
Units in high-demand buildings sell quicker.

Unit Demand is a measure of quickly units in a particular building sell as compared with other buildings in the neighborhood. Units in high-demand buildings sell more quickly.

For Sale 0 For Sale

2539.5 Prairie Avenue Inventory & Sale History

UnitSize (sqft)BedsBathsDays On MarketDateStatusPrice
Unit 3W3W85011932026-01-06
MLS#: 12488464 		Closed$207,500
Unit 3E3E-11832024-09-04
MLS#: 12082694 		Closed$200,500
Unit 1W1W65011292024-06-21
MLS#: 12063801 		Closed$190,000
Unit 1W
1W

1 Beds

1 Baths

650 sqft

DateStatusPrice
2024-06-21Closed$190,000
MLS#: 12063801
Days On Market29
Unit 3E
3E

1 Beds

1 Baths

0 sqft

DateStatusPrice
2024-09-04Closed$200,500
MLS#: 12082694
Days On Market83
Unit 3W
3W

1 Beds

1 Baths

850 sqft

DateStatusPrice
2026-01-06Closed$207,500
MLS#: 12488464
Days On Market93
View Complete Unit Listing HistorySource By: MRED

Amenities

Living in this building means you’ll have easy access to bike trails and a dedicated bike room, making your daily commute or leisurely rides an enjoyable experience. Whether you’re cycling to work or exploring the beautiful local parks, you’ll appreciate the bike-friendly features this condo has to offer. The community atmosphere here is welcoming, and the amenities reflect a lifestyle that prioritizes both relaxation and activity.

Next

Amenities Description

Living in this building means you’ll have easy access to bike trails and a dedicated bike room, making your daily commute or leisurely rides an enjoyable experience. Whether you’re cycling to work or exploring the beautiful local parks, you’ll appreciate the bike-friendly features this condo has to offer. The community atmosphere here is welcoming, and the amenities reflect a lifestyle that prioritizes both relaxation and activity.

Parking
Parking
Locker
Locker
Concierge
Concierge
Elevator(s)
Elevator(s)
Central AC
Central AC
Pool
Pool
Fitness Center
Fitness Center
-
Visitors Parking
Visitors Parking
Next

Amenities

Security Door Lock(s)

Security Door Lock(s)

Bike Room/Bike Trails

Bike Room/Bike Trails

Storage

Storage

Policies

One of the standout benefits of life at 2539.5 Prairie Avenue? It's a pet-friendly environment! Both cats and dogs are welcome, which means your furry friends can be part of your new adventure. The building policies include a number limit on pets, ensuring a serene and pleasant living space for all.

Pet Allowed
Pet Allowed
BBQ Permitted
BBQ Permitted
Sublet Allowed
Sublet Allowed
Short-term Rental Allowed
Short-term Rental Allowed

Compare with Buildings in the Neighbourhood (Last 12 Months)

Compare building's average price/sq. ft. and HOA fees/sq. ft. to buildings nearby

Building NameAvg price per square footAVG HOA FEE per square foot (Monthly)
2539.5 Prairie Avenue--
2009 Harrison Street$246/sqft.$3 /sqft.
2009 Harrison St$246/sqft.$3 /sqft.
2515 Prairie Ave$398/sqft.$3 /sqft.
Lincolnwood$398/sqft.$3 /sqft.
2615 Prairie Avenue$491/sqft.$4 /sqft.

Nearby Schools

2539.5 Prairie Avenue is positioned near local schools serving the surrounding area. Educational institutions within a 2-mile radius improve daily accessibility. Families benefit from shorter commutes and convenience. This well-located area supports comfortable living.

Haven Middle School

C-
Public|Grades 6–8
2417 Prairie Ave|0.2 miles away

Kingsley Elementary School

B
Public|Grades KG–5
2300 Green Bay Rd|0.34 miles away

Lincolnwood Elementary School

B-
Public|Grades KG–5
2600 Colfax St|0.55 miles away

Kingsway Preparatory School

--
Private|Grades PK–4
2010 Dewey Ave|0.68 miles away

St Francis Xavier School

--
Private|Grades PK–8
808 Linden Ave|0.71 miles away

Midwest Montessori School

--
Private|Grades PK–KG
926 Noyes St|0.89 miles away
Next

Schools

arrow rightWhat to know about schoolsarrow right
Next

Description

2539.5 Prairie Avenue is positioned near local schools serving the surrounding area. Educational institutions within a 2-mile radius improve daily accessibility. Families benefit from shorter commutes and convenience. This well-located area supports comfortable living.

Haven Middle School

C-
Public|Grades 6–8
2417 Prairie Ave|Less than 1 Mile Away

Kingsley Elementary School

B
Public|Grades KG–5
2300 Green Bay Rd|Less than 1 Mile Away

Lincolnwood Elementary School

B-
Public|Grades KG–5
2600 Colfax St|Less than 1 Mile Away

Kingsway Preparatory School

--
Private|Grades PK–4
2010 Dewey Ave|Less than 1 Mile Away

St Francis Xavier School

--
Private|Grades PK–8
808 Linden Ave|Less than 1 Mile Away

Midwest Montessori School

--
Private|Grades PK–KG
926 Noyes St|Less than 1 Mile Away

Willard Elementary School

A-
Public|Grades KG–5
2700 Hurd Ave|Less than 1 Mile Away

Central Elementary School

A+
Public|Grades KG–4
910 Central Ave|Less than 1 Mile Away

Baker Demonstration School

--
Private|Grades PK–8
201 Sheridan Rd|Less than 1 Mile Away

McKenzie Elementary School

A+
Public|Grades KG–4
649 Prairie Ave|Less than 1 Mile Away

Orrington Elementary School

A+
Public|Grades KG–5
2636 Orrington Ave|1.04 Miles Away

Evanston Township High School

A-
Public|Grades 9–12
1600 Dodge Ave|1.21 Miles Away

Roycemore School

--
Private|Grades PK–12
1200 Davis St|1.31 Miles Away

Dewey Elementary School

A
Public|Grades KG–5
1551 Wesley Ave|1.33 Miles Away

The Barbereux School

--
Private|Grades PK–1
3333 Culver St|1.39 Miles Away

Joseph E Hill Education Center

--
Public|Grades PK–PK
1500 McDaniel Ave|1.39 Miles Away

Walker Elementary School

B+
Public|Grades KG–5
3601 Church St|1.47 Miles Away

Dr Ml King Jr Literary & Fine Arts School

B-
Public|Grades KG–8
2424 Lake St|1.47 Miles Away

Highland Elementary School

B
Public|Grades KG–5
9700 Crawford Ave|1.52 Miles Away

Beacon Academy

--
Private|Grades 9–12
1574 Sherman Ave|1.51 Miles Away

St Joseph School

--
Private|Grades PK–KG
1740 Lake Ave|1.53 Miles Away

Dr Bessie Rhodes School Global Studies

C
Public|Grades KG–8
3701 Davis St|1.69 Miles Away

Eths Day School

--
Public|Grades 9–12
1233 Hartrey Ave|1.69 Miles Away

Mesivta Shaarei Adirim

--
Private|Grades 9–11
9220 Crawford Ave|1.78 Miles Away

Ronald Knox Montessori School

--
Private|Grades PK–KG
2031 Elmwood Ave|1.85 Miles Away

Highcrest Middle School

A+
Public|Grades 5–6
569 Hunter Rd|1.85 Miles Away

Chiaravalle Montessori School

--
Private|Grades PK–8
425 Dempster St|1.91 Miles Away

Transit

2539.5 Prairie Avenue enjoys proximity to 50+ public transit options throughout Evanston. Located within a 2-mile radius, these connections enable easy commuting and dependable travel. Residents benefit from reduced reliance on private vehicles. A well-served transit location supports sustainable urban living.

3rd / Central

1.03 miles away|20 min walk

3rd St & Central Ave

1.02 miles away|20 min walk

3rd St & Greenleaf Ave

0.94 miles away|19 min walk

4th St & Greenleaf Ave

0.89 miles away|17 min walk

4th St & Linden Ave

0.81 miles away|16 min walk

Ashland Ave & Simpson St

0.63 miles away|13 min walk
Next

Transit

arrow rightWhat to know about transitarrow right
Next

Description

2539.5 Prairie Avenue enjoys proximity to 50+ public transit options throughout Evanston. Located within a 2-mile radius, these connections enable easy commuting and dependable travel. Residents benefit from reduced reliance on private vehicles. A well-served transit location supports sustainable urban living.

3rd / Central

1.03 miles away|20 min walk

3rd St & Central Ave

1.02 miles away|20 min walk

3rd St & Greenleaf Ave

0.94 miles away|19 min walk

4th St & Greenleaf Ave

0.89 miles away|17 min walk

4th St & Linden Ave

0.81 miles away|16 min walk

Ashland Ave & Simpson St

0.63 miles away|13 min walk

Ashland & Payne Street

0.55 miles away|11 min walk

Ashland & Simpson

0.63 miles away|13 min walk

Central Ave & 10th St

0.89 miles away|18 min walk

Central Ave & 11th St

0.91 miles away|18 min walk

Central Ave & 12th St

0.96 miles away|19 min walk

Central Ave & 4th St

0.96 miles away|19 min walk

Central Ave & 5th St

0.93 miles away|18 min walk

Central Ave & 6th St

0.9 miles away|18 min walk

Central Ave & 7th St

0.88 miles away|17 min walk

Central Ave & 8th St

0.87 miles away|17 min walk

Central Ave & 9th St

0.88 miles away|17 min walk

Central Ave & Green Bay Rd

0.98 miles away|19 min walk

Central Ave & Wilmette Ave

0.94 miles away|19 min walk

Central & Orrington

1.05 miles away|21 min walk

Central (Purple)

0.74 miles away|15 min walk

Central-Purple

0.74 miles away|15 min walk

Central & Sheridan

1.17 miles away|23 min walk

Central St.

0.1 miles away|2 min walk

Central Street & Asbury

0.55 miles away|11 min walk

Central Street & Ashland

0.31 miles away|6 min walk

Central Street & Bennett

0.54 miles away|11 min walk

Central Street & Broadway/Poplar

0.1 miles away|2 min walk

Central Street & Central Park

0.91 miles away|18 min walk

Central Street & Cowper

1.24 miles away|24 min walk

Central Street & Crawford

1.4 miles away|27 min walk

Central Street & Eastwood

0.22 miles away|5 min walk

Central Street & Ewing

0.64 miles away|13 min walk

Central Street & Girard (Purple Line)

0.73 miles away|14 min walk

Central Street & Green Bay Rd

0.05 miles away|2 min walk

Central Street & Hartrey

0.17 miles away|4 min walk

Central Street & Jackson

0.4 miles away|8 min walk

Central Street & Lawndale

1.05 miles away|21 min walk

Central Street & Lincolnwood

0.77 miles away|15 min walk

Central Street & McDaniel

0.39 miles away|8 min walk

Central Street & Prospect

1.31 miles away|26 min walk

Central Street & Reese

0.71 miles away|14 min walk

Central Street & Ridge

0.84 miles away|17 min walk

Central Street & Sherman

0.93 miles away|18 min walk

Central Street & Walnut

0.24 miles away|5 min walk

Chicago Ave & Dempster St

1.85 miles away|36 min walk

Chicago Ave & Grove St

1.66 miles away|32 min walk

Chicago Ave & Hamilton St

1.99 miles away|39 min walk

Chicago Ave & Lake St

1.68 miles away|33 min walk

Chicago Avenue & Church

1.55 miles away|30 min walk

The Neighbourhood: 2539.5 Prairie Avenue

Similar Buildings Nearby

Add to favoritesAdd to favorites (hover)
2539.5 Prairie Ave
25395 Prairie Ave, Evanston, IL
Click to see listings
Add to favoritesAdd to favorites (hover)
906 Greenwood
906 Greenwood, Evanston, IL
Click to see listings
Add to favoritesAdd to favorites (hover)
2314 Sherman
2314 Sherman, Evanston, IL
Click to see listings
Add to favoritesAdd to favorites (hover)
2314 Sherman
2314 Sherman, Evanston, IL
Click to see listings
Add to favoritesAdd to favorites (hover)
2539.5 Prairie Ave
25395 Prairie Ave, Evanston, IL
Click to see listings
Add to favoritesAdd to favorites (hover)
906 Greenwood
906 Greenwood, Evanston, IL
Click to see listings
Add to favoritesAdd to favorites (hover)
2314 Sherman
2314 Sherman, Evanston, IL
Click to see listings
View All Similar Buildings

2539.5 Prairie Avenue Demographics

Age Demographics

0–14 Years

18.81%

15–29 Years

24.27%

30–44 Years

16.07%

45–59 Years

17.77%

60+ Years

23.08%

Commute

15.37%

Transit

13.18%

Walk

45.54%

Drive

2.14%

Bike

Housing Ownership

58.77%

Owner Occupied

41.23%

Rental Units

Household Types

Single Family
28.43%
Multi Family
6.8%
Single Person
32.26%
Multi Person
67.74%

Average Income

Household:$11,720,881.96 /yr

Individual:$7,498,633.9 /yr

Education

Bachelors Degree30.09%
High School College9.13%
Diploma4.12%
Post Graduate43.08%
Others13.58%
Next

Education

Diploma4.12%
Post Graduate43.08%
Others13.58%
Get the HelloCondo Newsletter
Real-estate tips, insights, and market reports in your inbox.
Newsletter
  1. Home
  2. /Evanston, IL
  3. /
    2539.5 Prairie Avenue
Nearby Cities
Hanover Park
Buildings
2009 Harrison St
2009 Harrison Street
2320 Central St
2320 Central Street
2324 Central St
2324 Central Street
2333 Central St
2333 Central Street
2455 Prairie
2457 Prairie Ave
2501 Prairie Ave
2515 Prairie Ave
2539.5 Prairie Ave
2539.5 Prairie Avenue
2615 Prairie Ave
2615 Prairie Avenue
Jeffersonian
Lincolnwood
Neighborhoods
Albany ParkAndersonvilleArmour Square
AshburnBeverlyBig Woods MarmionBlackhawkBridgeportBucktownClearingEdison ParkEmerald LawnsEola YardsFar SoutheastForest GlenForest ParkGalewoodGrand CrossingLincoln ParkSt. John
ZIP Codes
600266007060098
6014260152601556018860404604196043660439604526047760487605526055660564606216062660653
Community
1056 - 1054 West Lawrence Condominiums1059 - 1103 West North Shore Condominiums1060 - 1058 West Lawrence Condominiums
1107 - 1109 West North Shore Condominiums1138 - 1142 West North Shore Condominiums1138 West Catalpa Condominiums1217 - 1219 West North Shore Condominiums1218 - 1220 West Carmen Avenue Condominiums1220 - 1224 West Chase Condominiums1226 - 1228 West Norwood Condominiums1227 - 1229 West Foster Condominiums1247 - 1253 West Leland Condominiums1248 - 1254 West Thorndale Condominiums1251 West Granville Condominiums1308 - 1318 West North Shore Condominiums1319 - 1327 West Sherwin Condominiums1321 - 1323 West Albion Condominiums1324 - 1326 West Hood Condominiums1325 - 1327 West Albion Condominiums1325 West Greenleaf Condominiums
HelloCondo Logo
HelloCondo Logo
HelloCondo Is The #1 Condo Search Platform And Real Estate Recommendation Engine. Search, Find And Buy The Perfect Condo And Get Matched With The Best Agents. Finding A Condo Has Never Been So Easy.

HelloCondo is a division of HelloCasa, LLC

FacebookIconInstagramIconXIconRedditIcon

HelloCondo

Find A RealtorTerms of UsePrivacy PolicyCalifornia Privacy NoticeAccessibility PolicyCCPA Notice on CollectionDMCABrowseNYS Standard Operating ProcedureNYS Fair Housing Notice

Contact

LocationIcon
300 Galleria Pkwy SE, Suite 1500,
Atlanta, GA 30339
PhoneICon
(855) 625-0319
EmailIConhello@hellocondo.com
Contact Us

For Sale

Condos for saleTownhomes for sale
AgentIcon
LocationIcon

Berkshire Hathaway Starck Real Estate

Paul Ambrogio

Serving Chicago and all of Northern IL

13300 IL RT 47

Huntley, Illinois 60142

PhoneICon847-668-3774
EmailIConpaul@illinoispropertysearch.com
© HelloCondo 2026. All Rights Reserved.