HeaderIcon
  1. Agent Logo

Explore by Metro

  • Atlanta
  • Baltimore
  • Boston
  • Bronx
  • Brooklyn
  • Chicago
  • Los Angeles
  • Manhattan
  • Miami
  • Nashville
  • Orlando
  • Philadelphia
  • Phoenix
  • Queens
  • San Diego
  • San Jose
  • Tampa
  • Washington
HeaderIcon

Explore by Metro

  • Atlanta
  • Baltimore
  • Boston
  • Bronx
  • Brooklyn
  • Chicago
  • Los Angeles
  • Manhattan
  • Miami
  • Nashville
  • Orlando
  • Philadelphia
  • Phoenix
  • Queens
  • San Diego
  • San Jose
  • Tampa
  • Washington
leftArrowBack to Search
  1. Home
  2. /
  3. Evanston, IL
  4. /
  5. 2457 Prairie Ave
Add to favoritesAdd to favorites (hover)
Save
leftArrow
Add to favoritesAdd to favorites (hover)

2457 Prairie Ave

2457 Prairie Ave, Evanston, IL, 60201
Lincolnwood

YEAR BUILT

1926

# STORIES

3

# TOTAL UNITS

6

UNIT SIZE RANGE

950-1,200 sqft

Description

The building at 2457 Prairie Ave sits in Evanston. This low-rise structure has three stories and holds six units. Built in 1926, it blends charm with modern living. Each unit offers two bedrooms, providing enough space for most households. Units range in size from 950 to 1,200 square feet. Prices for these homes fall between $286,000 and $308,000. The average closed price is $297,000, which breaks down to about $257 per square foot. Units spent an average of 43 days on the market recently. The building includes amenities like free laundry facilities, providing added convenience. Many units showcase high ceilings, crown moldings, and hardwood floors. Large windows allow natural light to fill the spaces, enhancing the ambiance. Residents might also appreciate built-in bookcases and granite countertops. The area around the building is vibrant. Central Street is just down the road with shops and restaurants. Nearby, the Evanston Arts Center offers cultural activities, while Haven Middle School serves local students. Lake Michigan is about a mile away, perfect for outdoor enjoyment. Parking options are available, adding to the ease of living here. The location allows for quick access to major roads and public transport. This makes commuting and exploring the surrounding area straightforward. Residents can enjoy being part of a friendly neighborhood.

Building ImageMLS ID #12352383
Building ImageMLS ID #12352383
Building Image
Building ImageView Listing

2457 Prairie Ave

2457 Prairie Ave, Evanston, IL, 60201


Lincolnwood

YEAR BUILT

1926

# STORIES

3

# TOTAL UNITS

6

UNIT SIZE RANGE

950-1,200 sqft

Description

The building at 2457 Prairie Ave sits in Evanston. This low-rise structure has three stories and holds six units. Built in 1926, it blends charm with modern living. Each unit offers two bedrooms, providing enough space for most households. Units range in size from 950 to 1,200 square feet. Prices for these homes fall between $286,000 and $308,000. The average closed price is $297,000, which breaks down to about $257 per square foot. Units spent an average of 43 days on the market recently. The building includes amenities like free laundry facilities, providing added convenience. Many units showcase high ceilings, crown moldings, and hardwood floors. Large windows allow natural light to fill the spaces, enhancing the ambiance. Residents might also appreciate built-in bookcases and granite countertops. The area around the building is vibrant. Central Street is just down the road with shops and restaurants. Nearby, the Evanston Arts Center offers cultural activities, while Haven Middle School serves local students. Lake Michigan is about a mile away, perfect for outdoor enjoyment. Parking options are available, adding to the ease of living here. The location allows for quick access to major roads and public transport. This makes commuting and exploring the surrounding area straightforward. Residents can enjoy being part of a friendly neighborhood.

Next

Description

The building at 2457 Prairie Ave sits in Evanston. This low-rise structure has three stories and holds six units. Built in 1926, it blends charm with modern living. Each unit offers two bedrooms, providing enough space for most households. Units range in size from 950 to 1,200 square feet. Prices for these homes fall between $286,000 and $308,000. The average closed price is $297,000, which breaks down to about $257 per square foot. Units spent an average of 43 days on the market recently. The building includes amenities like free laundry facilities, providing added convenience. Many units showcase high ceilings, crown moldings, and hardwood floors. Large windows allow natural light to fill the spaces, enhancing the ambiance. Residents might also appreciate built-in bookcases and granite countertops. The area around the building is vibrant. Central Street is just down the road with shops and restaurants. Nearby, the Evanston Arts Center offers cultural activities, while Haven Middle School serves local students. Lake Michigan is about a mile away, perfect for outdoor enjoyment. Parking options are available, adding to the ease of living here. The location allows for quick access to major roads and public transport. This makes commuting and exploring the surrounding area straightforward. Residents can enjoy being part of a friendly neighborhood.

2457 Prairie Ave Key Stats Last 12 months

Avg. Listed Price$299,500($259/Sqft.)

Avg. Sale Price$297,000($257/Sqft.)
Year over year list priceUp Arrow3.28%

Year over year sale priceDown Arrow 1.33%
Total Listings2 Listed

Total sold2 Sold
Average Days on Market43 days

Average HOA fees per sqft$3 /monthly
Next

Key Stats

Year over year list priceUp Arrow3.28%

Year over year sale priceDown Arrow1.33%
Total Listings2 Listed

Total sold2 Sold
Average Days on Market43 days

Average HOA fees per sqft$3 /monthly

Glen Gardens Estate Availability & Demand

Unit Availability

Medium
High availability buildings list units frequently.

Unit Availability helps to understand how often units in a particular building are listed for sale as compared with the neighborhood average. Units are rarely listed in buildings with low availability.

Unit Demand

Low
Units in high-demand buildings sell quicker.

Unit Demand is a measure of quickly units in a particular building sell as compared with other buildings in the neighborhood. Units in high-demand buildings sell more quickly.

For Sale 0 For Sale

2457 Prairie Ave Inventory & Sale History

UnitSize (sqft)BedsBathsDays On MarketDateStatusPrice
Unit 3C3C120021582025-06-27
MLS#: 12352383
Closed$308,000
Unit 1C1C-21282025-05-20
MLS#: 12342684
Closed$286,000
Unit 3C3C12002112024-06-28
MLS#: 12040301
Closed$301,000
Unit 1C
1C

2 Beds

1 Baths

0 sqft


DateStatusPrice
2025-05-20Closed$286,000
MLS#: 12342684
Days On Market28
Unit 3C
3C

2 Beds

1 Baths

1200 sqft


DateStatusPrice
2025-06-27Closed$308,000
MLS#: 12352383
Days On Market58
Unit 3C
3C

2 Beds

1 Baths

1200 sqft


DateStatusPrice
2024-06-28Closed$301,000
MLS#: 12040301
Days On Market1
View Complete Unit Listing HistorySource By: MRED

Amenities

One of the standout features of this building is the convenience of on-site laundry services, which can save you time and hassle. Imagine relief from the chore of hauling laundry back and forth — a welcome respite, especially for those busy days. While there may not be a long list of amenities, the building’s focus is on providing what’s truly needed for comfortable living.

Next

Amenities Description

One of the standout features of this building is the convenience of on-site laundry services, which can save you time and hassle. Imagine relief from the chore of hauling laundry back and forth — a welcome respite, especially for those busy days. While there may not be a long list of amenities, the building’s focus is on providing what’s truly needed for comfortable living.

Parking
Parking
Locker
Locker
Concierge
Concierge
Elevator(s)
Elevator(s)
Central AC
Central AC
Pool
Pool
Fitness Center
Fitness Center
-
Visitors Parking
Visitors Parking
Next

Amenities

Security Door Lock(s)

Security Door Lock(s)

Laundry

Laundry

Coin Laundry

Coin Laundry

Storage

Storage

Policies

At 2457 Prairie Ave, you’ll find a welcoming attitude towards pets, with policies allowing both cats and dogs to reside in the building. This is a huge plus for animal lovers looking to share their new home with furry companions. However, be aware of the specific number limit outlined in the building policies, which ensures a harmonious living environment for everyone.

Next

Amenities Description

At 2457 Prairie Ave, you’ll find a welcoming attitude towards pets, with policies allowing both cats and dogs to reside in the building. This is a huge plus for animal lovers looking to share their new home with furry companions. However, be aware of the specific number limit outlined in the building policies, which ensures a harmonious living environment for everyone.

Pet Allowed
Pet Allowed
BBQ Permitted
BBQ Permitted
Sublet Allowed
Sublet Allowed
Short-term Rental Allowed
Short-term Rental Allowed

Compare with Buildings in the Neighbourhood (Last 12 Months)

Compare building's average price/sq. ft. and HOA fees/sq. ft. to buildings nearby

Building NameAvg price per square footAVG HOA FEE per square foot (Monthly)
2457 Prairie Ave$257/sqft.$3 /sqft.
Lincolnwood$257/sqft.$3 /sqft.
Lincolnwood$253/sqft.$3 /sqft.
2515 Prairie Ave$398/sqft.$3 /sqft.
Lincolnwood$398/sqft.$3 /sqft.
2009 Harrison St$246/sqft.$3 /sqft.

Nearby Schools

In , 2457 Prairie Ave benefits from nearby schools within easy reach. Educational institutions within 2 miles reduce travel time for families. This convenient access supports balanced daily routines. The location promotes comfortable urban living.

Haven Middle School

C-
Public|Grades 6–8
2417 Prairie Ave|0.1 miles away

Kingsley Elementary School

B
Public|Grades KG–5
2300 Green Bay Rd|0.24 miles away

Lincolnwood Elementary School

B-
Public|Grades KG–5
2600 Colfax St|0.57 miles away

Kingsway Preparatory School

--
Private|Grades PK–4
2010 Dewey Ave|0.59 miles away

St Francis Xavier School

--
Private|Grades PK–8
808 Linden Ave|0.79 miles away

Midwest Montessori School

--
Private|Grades PK–KG
926 Noyes St|0.81 miles away
Next

Schools

arrow rightWhat to know about schoolsarrow right
Next

Description

In , 2457 Prairie Ave benefits from nearby schools within easy reach. Educational institutions within 2 miles reduce travel time for families. This convenient access supports balanced daily routines. The location promotes comfortable urban living.

Haven Middle School

C-
Public|Grades 6–8
2417 Prairie Ave|Less than 1 Mile Away

Kingsley Elementary School

B
Public|Grades KG–5
2300 Green Bay Rd|Less than 1 Mile Away

Lincolnwood Elementary School

B-
Public|Grades KG–5
2600 Colfax St|Less than 1 Mile Away

Kingsway Preparatory School

--
Private|Grades PK–4
2010 Dewey Ave|Less than 1 Mile Away

St Francis Xavier School

--
Private|Grades PK–8
808 Linden Ave|Less than 1 Mile Away

Midwest Montessori School

--
Private|Grades PK–KG
926 Noyes St|Less than 1 Mile Away

Baker Demonstration School

--
Private|Grades PK–8
201 Sheridan Rd|Less than 1 Mile Away

Willard Elementary School

A-
Public|Grades KG–5
2700 Hurd Ave|Less than 1 Mile Away

Orrington Elementary School

A+
Public|Grades KG–5
2636 Orrington Ave|1.00 Miles Away

Central Elementary School

A+
Public|Grades KG–4
910 Central Ave|1.01 Miles Away

McKenzie Elementary School

A+
Public|Grades KG–4
649 Prairie Ave|1.09 Miles Away

Evanston Township High School

A-
Public|Grades 9–12
1600 Dodge Ave|1.14 Miles Away

Roycemore School

--
Private|Grades PK–12
1200 Davis St|1.22 Miles Away

Dewey Elementary School

A
Public|Grades KG–5
1551 Wesley Ave|1.24 Miles Away

Joseph E Hill Education Center

--
Public|Grades PK–PK
1500 McDaniel Ave|1.33 Miles Away

Dr Ml King Jr Literary & Fine Arts School

B-
Public|Grades KG–8
2424 Lake St|1.42 Miles Away

Beacon Academy

--
Private|Grades 9–12
1574 Sherman Ave|1.42 Miles Away

The Barbereux School

--
Private|Grades PK–1
3333 Culver St|1.44 Miles Away

Walker Elementary School

B+
Public|Grades KG–5
3601 Church St|1.45 Miles Away

Highland Elementary School

B
Public|Grades KG–5
9700 Crawford Ave|1.55 Miles Away

St Joseph School

--
Private|Grades PK–KG
1740 Lake Ave|1.63 Miles Away

Eths Day School

--
Public|Grades 9–12
1233 Hartrey Ave|1.62 Miles Away

Dr Bessie Rhodes School Global Studies

C
Public|Grades KG–8
3701 Davis St|1.67 Miles Away

Mesivta Shaarei Adirim

--
Private|Grades 9–11
9220 Crawford Ave|1.78 Miles Away

Chiaravalle Montessori School

--
Private|Grades PK–8
425 Dempster St|1.82 Miles Away

Highcrest Middle School

A+
Public|Grades 5–6
569 Hunter Rd|1.93 Miles Away

Ronald Knox Montessori School

--
Private|Grades PK–KG
2031 Elmwood Ave|1.94 Miles Away

Washington Elementary School

B-
Public|Grades KG–5
914 Ashland Ave|1.94 Miles Away

Nichols Middle School

B+
Public|Grades 6–8
800 Greenleaf St|1.95 Miles Away

Transit

With nearby public transportation, 2457 Prairie Ave offers strong connectivity across Evanston. Access to Bus, Metro, Rail within a 2-mile radius supports efficient commuting. Reliable transit routes improve travel convenience for residents. This location provides practical urban accessibility.

3rd / Central

1.07 miles away|21 min walk

3rd St & Central Ave

1.06 miles away|21 min walk

3rd St & Greenleaf Ave

0.98 miles away|19 min walk

4th St & Greenleaf Ave

0.93 miles away|18 min walk

4th St & Linden Ave

0.85 miles away|17 min walk

Ashland Ave & Simpson St

0.54 miles away|11 min walk
Next

Transit

arrow rightWhat to know about transitarrow right
Next

Description

With nearby public transportation, 2457 Prairie Ave offers strong connectivity across Evanston. Access to Bus, Metro, Rail within a 2-mile radius supports efficient commuting. Reliable transit routes improve travel convenience for residents. This location provides practical urban accessibility.

3rd / Central

1.07 miles away|21 min walk

3rd St & Central Ave

1.06 miles away|21 min walk

3rd St & Greenleaf Ave

0.98 miles away|19 min walk

4th St & Greenleaf Ave

0.93 miles away|18 min walk

4th St & Linden Ave

0.85 miles away|17 min walk

Ashland Ave & Simpson St

0.54 miles away|11 min walk

Ashland & Payne Street

0.46 miles away|9 min walk

Ashland & Simpson

0.54 miles away|11 min walk

Central Ave & 10th St

0.98 miles away|19 min walk

Central Ave & 11th St

1 miles away|20 min walk

Central Ave & 12th St

1.06 miles away|21 min walk

Central Ave & 4th St

1.01 miles away|20 min walk

Central Ave & 5th St

0.98 miles away|19 min walk

Central Ave & 6th St

0.96 miles away|19 min walk

Central Ave & 7th St

0.95 miles away|19 min walk

Central Ave & 8th St

0.95 miles away|19 min walk

Central Ave & 9th St

0.96 miles away|19 min walk

Central Ave & Green Bay Rd

1.08 miles away|21 min walk

Central Ave & Wilmette Ave

1.04 miles away|20 min walk

Central & Orrington

1 miles away|20 min walk

Central (Purple)

0.69 miles away|14 min walk

Central-Purple

0.69 miles away|14 min walk

Central & Sheridan

1.12 miles away|22 min walk

Central St.

0.11 miles away|3 min walk

Central Street & Asbury

0.5 miles away|10 min walk

Central Street & Ashland

0.27 miles away|6 min walk

Central Street & Bennett

0.61 miles away|12 min walk

Central Street & Broadway/Poplar

0.11 miles away|3 min walk

Central Street & Central Park

0.97 miles away|19 min walk

Central Street & Cowper

1.3 miles away|25 min walk

Central Street & Crawford

1.46 miles away|28 min walk

Central Street & Eastwood

0.19 miles away|4 min walk

Central Street & Ewing

0.7 miles away|14 min walk

Central Street & Girard (Purple Line)

0.68 miles away|14 min walk

Central Street & Green Bay Rd

0.1 miles away|2 min walk

Central Street & Hartrey

0.25 miles away|5 min walk

Central Street & Jackson

0.36 miles away|7 min walk

Central Street & Lawndale

1.11 miles away|22 min walk

Central Street & Lincolnwood

0.84 miles away|17 min walk

Central Street & McDaniel

0.46 miles away|9 min walk

Central Street & Prospect

1.37 miles away|27 min walk

Central Street & Reese

0.77 miles away|15 min walk

Central Street & Ridge

0.79 miles away|16 min walk

Central Street & Sherman

0.88 miles away|17 min walk

Central Street & Walnut

0.31 miles away|7 min walk

Chicago Ave & Dempster St

1.75 miles away|34 min walk

Chicago Ave & Greenleaf St

1.98 miles away|38 min walk

Chicago Ave & Grove St

1.57 miles away|31 min walk

Chicago Ave & Hamilton St

1.89 miles away|37 min walk

Chicago Ave & Lake St

1.59 miles away|31 min walk

The Neighbourhood: 2457 Prairie Ave

Similar Buildings Nearby

Add to favoritesAdd to favorites (hover)
Lincolnwood
2457 Prairie Avenue, Evanston, IL
Click to see listings
Add to favoritesAdd to favorites (hover)
Lincolnwood
2501 Prairie Avenue, Evanston, IL
Click to see listings
Add to favoritesAdd to favorites (hover)
2501 Prairie Ave
2501 Prairie Ave, Evanston, IL
Click to see listings
Add to favoritesAdd to favorites (hover)
1426 Chicago Avenue
1426 Chicago Avenue, Evanston, IL
Click to see listings
Add to favoritesAdd to favorites (hover)
Lincolnwood
2457 Prairie Avenue, Evanston, IL
Click to see listings
Add to favoritesAdd to favorites (hover)
Lincolnwood
2501 Prairie Avenue, Evanston, IL
Click to see listings
Add to favoritesAdd to favorites (hover)
2501 Prairie Ave
2501 Prairie Ave, Evanston, IL
Click to see listings
View All Similar Buildings

2457 Prairie Ave Demographics

This neighborhood indicates a good mix of people which makes it a good place for families. About 18.05% are children aged 0–14, 26.85% are young adults between 15–29, 15.83% are adults aged 30–44, 16.85% are in the 45–59 range and 22.43% are seniors aged 60 and above. Commuting options are also varying where 45.25% of residents relying on driving, while others prefer public transit around 14.78%, walking around 14.78%, biking around 2.31%, allowing residents to choose travel modes that best fit their daily routines. Most homes in the area are with 55.7% of units owner occupied and 44.3% are rented. The neighborhood offers different household types. About 28.05% are single family homes and 6.53% are multi family units. Around 32.89% are single-person households, while 67.11% are multi person households. This mix works well for families, roommates, and individuals. Education levels in the neighborhood vary widely where 29.88% of residents have bachelor’s degrees. Around 9.67% have high school or college education. Another 4.39% hold diplomas while 42.12% have completed postgraduate studies. The remaining are 13.95% with other types of qualifications.

Next

Demographics Description

This neighborhood indicates a good mix of people which makes it a good place for families. About 18.05% are children aged 0–14, 26.85% are young adults between 15–29, 15.83% are adults aged 30–44, 16.85% are in the 45–59 range and 22.43% are seniors aged 60 and above. Commuting options are also varying where 45.25% of residents relying on driving, while others prefer public transit around 14.78%, walking around 14.78%, biking around 2.31%, allowing residents to choose travel modes that best fit their daily routines. Most homes in the area are with 55.7% of units owner occupied and 44.3% are rented. The neighborhood offers different household types. About 28.05% are single family homes and 6.53% are multi family units. Around 32.89% are single-person households, while 67.11% are multi person households. This mix works well for families, roommates, and individuals. Education levels in the neighborhood vary widely where 29.88% of residents have bachelor’s degrees. Around 9.67% have high school or college education. Another 4.39% hold diplomas while 42.12% have completed postgraduate studies. The remaining are 13.95% with other types of qualifications.

Age Demographics

0–14 Years

18.05%

15–29 Years

26.85%

30–44 Years

15.83%

45–59 Years

16.85%

60+ Years

22.43%

Commute

14.78%

Transit

14.78%

Walk

45.25%

Drive

2.31%

Bike

Housing Ownership

55.7%

Owner Occupied

44.3%

Rental Units

Household Types

Single Family
28.05%
Multi Family
6.53%
Single Person
32.89%
Multi Person
67.11%

Average Income

Household:$11,062,898.56 /yr

Individual:$7,140,779.27 /yr

Education

Bachelors Degree29.88%
High School College9.67%
Diploma4.39%
Post Graduate42.12%
Others13.95%
Next

Education

Diploma4.39%
Post Graduate42.12%
Others13.95%
Get the HelloCondo Newsletter
Real-estate tips, insights, and market reports in your inbox.
Newsletter
  1. Home
  2. /Evanston, IL
  3. /
    2457 Prairie Ave
Nearby Cities
Oswego
Buildings
1320 Central St
2009 Harrison St
2009 Harrison Street
2320 Central St
2320 Central Street
2324 Central St
2324 Central Street
2333 Central St
2333 Central Street
2455 Prairie
2457 Prairie Ave
2501 Prairie Ave
2515 Prairie Ave
2539.5 Prairie Ave
2539.5 Prairie Avenue
2615 Prairie Ave
2615 Prairie Avenue
Lincolnwood
Neighborhoods
AustinBronzevilleBucktown
Chicago Midway International AirportEdgewaterEola YardsGalewoodKenwoodLincoln SquareMidland Avenue WestMontclareMount GreenwoodNear West GalenaNew LenoxNorwood ParkOld TownRichard's GroveRoselandSouth DeeringWashington Park
ZIP Codes
600046003060035
6005360070600726007660081600856017960194601996040360408604156043860439604456047660536
Community
1056 - 1054 West Lawrence Condominiums1059 - 1103 West North Shore Condominiums1060 - 1058 West Lawrence Condominiums
1107 - 1109 West North Shore Condominiums1138 - 1142 West North Shore Condominiums1138 West Catalpa Condominiums1217 - 1219 West North Shore Condominiums1218 - 1220 West Carmen Avenue Condominiums1220 - 1224 West Chase Condominiums1226 - 1228 West Norwood Condominiums1227 - 1229 West Foster Condominiums1247 - 1253 West Leland Condominiums1248 - 1254 West Thorndale Condominiums1251 West Granville Condominiums1308 - 1318 West North Shore Condominiums1319 - 1327 West Sherwin Condominiums1321 - 1323 West Albion Condominiums1324 - 1326 West Hood Condominiums1325 - 1327 West Albion Condominiums1325 West Greenleaf Condominiums
HelloCondo Logo
HelloCondo Logo
HelloCondo Is The #1 Condo Search Platform And Real Estate Recommendation Engine. Search, Find And Buy The Perfect Condo And Get Matched With The Best Agents. Finding A Condo Has Never Been So Easy.

HelloCondo is a division of HelloCasa, LLC

FacebookIconInstagramIconXIconRedditIcon

HelloCondo

Find A RealtorTerms of UsePrivacy PolicyCalifornia Privacy NoticeAccessibility PolicyCCPA Notice on CollectionDMCABrowseNYS Standard Operating ProcedureNYS Fair Housing Notice

Contact

LocationIcon
300 Galleria Pkwy SE, Suite 1500,
Atlanta, GA 30339
PhoneICon
(855) 625-0319
EmailIConhello@hellocondo.com
Contact Us

For Sale

Condos for saleTownhomes for sale
AgentIcon
LocationIcon

Berkshire Hathaway Starck Real Estate

Paul Ambrogio

Serving Chicago and all of Northern IL

13300 IL RT 47

Huntley, Illinois 60142

PhoneICon847-668-3774
EmailIConpaul@illinoispropertysearch.com
© HelloCondo 2026. All Rights Reserved.