HeaderIcon
  1. Agent Logo

Explore by Metro

  • Atlanta
  • Baltimore
  • Boston
  • Bronx
  • Brooklyn
  • Chicago
  • Los Angeles
  • Manhattan
  • Miami
  • Nashville
  • Orlando
  • Philadelphia
  • Phoenix
  • Queens
  • San Diego
  • San Jose
  • Tampa
  • Washington
HeaderIcon

Explore by Metro

  • Atlanta
  • Baltimore
  • Boston
  • Bronx
  • Brooklyn
  • Chicago
  • Los Angeles
  • Manhattan
  • Miami
  • Nashville
  • Orlando
  • Philadelphia
  • Phoenix
  • Queens
  • San Diego
  • San Jose
  • Tampa
  • Washington
leftArrowBack to Search
  1. Home
  2. /
  3. Manhattan, NY
  4. /
  5. 251 W 89th St
Add to favoritesAdd to favorites (hover)
Save
leftArrow
Add to favoritesAdd to favorites (hover)

251 W 89th St

251 W 89th St, Manhattan, NY, 10024

YEAR BUILT

1910

# STORIES

12

# TOTAL UNITS

42

UNIT SIZE RANGE

1,138-2,111 sqft

Description

251 W 89th St sits in the Upper West Side of Manhattan. It lies near the intersection of Central Park West and West 96th Street. This high-rise building connects easily to Riverside Park and is close to the Hudson River. It stands out with its pre-war architecture and charm. The building has 12 stories and contains 42 condominium units. Its construction finished in 1910. Units vary in size from 1,138 to 2,111 square feet, providing plenty of space. The layout includes options for 2 to 5 bedrooms. Many units feature oversize windows and high ceilings over 10 feet. Prices for units range from $3,395,000 to $5,275,000. The lowest sold price in the past year was approximately $1,775,000. The average closed price is around $2,217,509. The average price per square foot stands at $1,138. Units typically spend about 208 days on the market. The building has many reliable amenities. A doorman welcomes residents and their guests. A live-in superintendent ensures smooth operations. The building also includes a marble lobby and bike storage. Residents enjoy a landscaped roof deck for relaxing and taking in city views. Nearby dining options include 2425 Broadway Chao Restaurant and Cibo E Vino. For families, the Abraham Joshua Heschel School lies close by. The location provides easy access to subway lines, which make commuting straightforward. Overall, this building blends classic architectural elegance with modern living comforts.

Building ImageMLS ID #RLS10004812
Building ImageMLS ID #RLS20014615
Building Image
Building ImageView Listing

251 W 89th St

251 W 89th St, Manhattan, NY, 10024

YEAR BUILT

1910

# STORIES

12

# TOTAL UNITS

42

UNIT SIZE RANGE

1,138-2,111 sqft

Description

251 W 89th St sits in the Upper West Side of Manhattan. It lies near the intersection of Central Park West and West 96th Street. This high-rise building connects easily to Riverside Park and is close to the Hudson River. It stands out with its pre-war architecture and charm. The building has 12 stories and contains 42 condominium units. Its construction finished in 1910. Units vary in size from 1,138 to 2,111 square feet, providing plenty of space. The layout includes options for 2 to 5 bedrooms. Many units feature oversize windows and high ceilings over 10 feet. Prices for units range from $3,395,000 to $5,275,000. The lowest sold price in the past year was approximately $1,775,000. The average closed price is around $2,217,509. The average price per square foot stands at $1,138. Units typically spend about 208 days on the market. The building has many reliable amenities. A doorman welcomes residents and their guests. A live-in superintendent ensures smooth operations. The building also includes a marble lobby and bike storage. Residents enjoy a landscaped roof deck for relaxing and taking in city views. Nearby dining options include 2425 Broadway Chao Restaurant and Cibo E Vino. For families, the Abraham Joshua Heschel School lies close by. The location provides easy access to subway lines, which make commuting straightforward. Overall, this building blends classic architectural elegance with modern living comforts.

Next

Description

251 W 89th St sits in the Upper West Side of Manhattan. It lies near the intersection of Central Park West and West 96th Street. This high-rise building connects easily to Riverside Park and is close to the Hudson River. It stands out with its pre-war architecture and charm. The building has 12 stories and contains 42 condominium units. Its construction finished in 1910. Units vary in size from 1,138 to 2,111 square feet, providing plenty of space. The layout includes options for 2 to 5 bedrooms. Many units feature oversize windows and high ceilings over 10 feet. Prices for units range from $3,395,000 to $5,275,000. The lowest sold price in the past year was approximately $1,775,000. The average closed price is around $2,217,509. The average price per square foot stands at $1,138. Units typically spend about 208 days on the market. The building has many reliable amenities. A doorman welcomes residents and their guests. A live-in superintendent ensures smooth operations. The building also includes a marble lobby and bike storage. Residents enjoy a landscaped roof deck for relaxing and taking in city views. Nearby dining options include 2425 Broadway Chao Restaurant and Cibo E Vino. For families, the Abraham Joshua Heschel School lies close by. The location provides easy access to subway lines, which make commuting straightforward. Overall, this building blends classic architectural elegance with modern living comforts.

251 W 89th St Key Stats Last 12 months

Avg. Listed Price$2,660,018($1261/Sqft.)
Avg. Sale Price$2,217,509($1138/Sqft.)
Year over year list priceUp Arrow29.21%
Year over year sale priceUp Arrow 9.37%
Total Listings1 Listed
Total sold2 Sold
Average Days on Market208 days
Average HOA fees per sqft$1 /monthly
Next

Key Stats

Year over year list priceUp Arrow29.21%
Year over year sale priceUp Arrow9.37%
Total Listings1 Listed
Total sold2 Sold
Average Days on Market208 days
Average HOA fees per sqft$1 /monthly

Glen Gardens Estate Availability & Demand

Unit Availability

Low
High availability buildings list units frequently.

Unit Availability helps to understand how often units in a particular building are listed for sale as compared with the neighborhood average. Units are rarely listed in buildings with low availability.

Unit Demand

Low
Units in high-demand buildings sell quicker.

Unit Demand is a measure of quickly units in a particular building sell as compared with other buildings in the neighborhood. Units in high-demand buildings sell more quickly.

For Sale 0 For Sale

251 W 89th St Inventory & Sale History

UnitSize (sqft)BedsBathsDays On MarketDateStatusPrice
Unit 12AB12AB-541292023-09-22
MLS#: RLS10904425 		Closed$5,275,000
Unit 10F10F211133792022-04-07
MLS#: RLS10765742 		Closed$2,875,000
Unit 12-F12-F211143982021-12-15
MLS#: RLS10740502 		Closed$3,395,000
Unit 10F
10F

3 Beds

3 Baths

2111 sqft

DateStatusPrice
2022-04-07Closed$2,875,000
MLS#: RLS10765742
Days On Market79
Unit 12-F
12-F

4 Beds

3 Baths

2111 sqft

DateStatusPrice
2021-12-15Closed$3,395,000
MLS#: RLS10740502
Days On Market98
Unit 12AB
12AB

5 Beds

4 Baths

- sqft

DateStatusPrice
2023-09-22Closed$5,275,000
MLS#: RLS10904425
Days On Market129
View Complete Unit Listing HistorySource By: REBNY

Amenities

Though specifics on amenities are not listed, living in such a building often means enjoying the perks of communal spaces, potentially including a fitness center, rooftop access, and lounges. Many condo residents also embrace the city lifestyle, with parks, cafes, and shops right at their doorstep. Imagine winding down your day in a cozy shared lounge or enjoying a book in the sunshine on a shared rooftop terrace.

Next

Amenities Description

Though specifics on amenities are not listed, living in such a building often means enjoying the perks of communal spaces, potentially including a fitness center, rooftop access, and lounges. Many condo residents also embrace the city lifestyle, with parks, cafes, and shops right at their doorstep. Imagine winding down your day in a cozy shared lounge or enjoying a book in the sunshine on a shared rooftop terrace.

Parking
Parking
Locker
Locker
Concierge
Concierge
Elevator(s)
Elevator(s)
Central AC
Central AC
Pool
Pool
Fitness Center
Fitness Center
-
Visitors Parking
Visitors Parking

Policies

The Admaston is also welcoming to furry friends! Cats and dogs are allowed, which can be a fantastic perk for pet parents looking for a pet-friendly environment in the city. Such policies can turn your new condo into more than just a home—it can be a place where your whole family thrives.

Pet Allowed
Pet Allowed
BBQ Permitted
BBQ Permitted
Sublet Allowed
Sublet Allowed
Short-term Rental Allowed
Short-term Rental Allowed

Compare with Buildings in the Neighbourhood (Last 12 Months)

Compare building's average price/sq. ft. and HOA fees/sq. ft. to buildings nearby

Building NameAvg price per square footAVG HOA FEE per square foot (Monthly)
251 W 89th St$1,138/sqft.$1 /sqft.
250 W 90th St$1,257/sqft.$1 /sqft.
600 W End Ave$699/sqft.$1 /sqft.
590 W End Ave$1,474/sqft.$1 /sqft.
250 W 88th St$1,303/sqft.$1 /sqft.
588 W End Ave$1,273/sqft.$1 /sqft.

Nearby Schools

251 W 89th St is located near 50+ schools throughout Manhattan. Schools within a 2-mile radius provide dependable access for families. Convenient proximity supports smoother daily routines. This location enhances residential comfort.

The Ideal School of Manhattan

--
Private|Grades KG–12
314 W 91st St|0.14 miles away

Stephen Gaynor School

--
Private|Grades UG–UG
148 W 90th St|0.15 miles away

The Geneva School of Manhattan

--
Private|Grades PK–8
138 W 90th St|0.17 miles away

P.S. 166 The Richard Rodgers School of The Arts and Technology

A-
Public|Grades KG–5
132 W 89th St|0.18 miles away

West Side Montessori School

--
Private|Grades PK–KG
309 W 92nd St|0.18 miles away

Yeshiva Ketana of Manhattan

--
Private|Grades PK–8
346 W 89th St|0.18 miles away
Next

Schools

arrow rightWhat to know about schoolsarrow right
Next

Description

251 W 89th St is located near 50+ schools throughout Manhattan. Schools within a 2-mile radius provide dependable access for families. Convenient proximity supports smoother daily routines. This location enhances residential comfort.

The Ideal School of Manhattan

--
Private|Grades KG–12
314 W 91st St|Less than 1 Mile Away

Stephen Gaynor School

--
Private|Grades UG–UG
148 W 90th St|Less than 1 Mile Away

The Geneva School of Manhattan

--
Private|Grades PK–8
138 W 90th St|Less than 1 Mile Away

P.S. 166 The Richard Rodgers School of The Arts and Technology

A-
Public|Grades KG–5
132 W 89th St|Less than 1 Mile Away

West Side Montessori School

--
Private|Grades PK–KG
309 W 92nd St|Less than 1 Mile Away

Yeshiva Ketana of Manhattan

--
Private|Grades PK–8
346 W 89th St|Less than 1 Mile Away

Metropolitan Montessori School

--
Private|Grades PK–6
325 W 85th St|Less than 1 Mile Away

PS 333 Manhattan School for Children

B+
Public|Grades KG–8
154 W 93rd St|Less than 1 Mile Away

Lafayette Academy

A
Public|Grades 6–8
154 W 93rd St|Less than 1 Mile Away

Community Action School-Middle School 258

B
Public|Grades 6–8
154 W 93rd St|Less than 1 Mile Away

The Smith School

--
Private|Grades 7–12
131 W 86th St # FL...|Less than 1 Mile Away

Gan Aliya

--
Private|Grades PK–KG
131 W 86th St|Less than 1 Mile Away

Bais Yaakov Bnos Aliya

--
Private|Grades 1–7
270 W 84th St|Less than 1 Mile Away

Manhattan Country School

--
Private|Grades PK–8
150 W 85th St|Less than 1 Mile Away

Manhattan Children's Center (The)

--
Private|Grades UG–UG
111 W 92nd St|Less than 1 Mile Away

Success Academy Charter School-Upper West

A-
Public|Grades KG–8
145 W 84th St Fl S...|Less than 1 Mile Away

Innovation Diploma Plus

F
Public|Grades 10–12
145 W 84th St|Less than 1 Mile Away

Frank Mccourt High School

B-
Public|Grades 9–12
145 W 84th St|Less than 1 Mile Away

Urban Assembly School for Green Careers (The)

D
Public|Grades 9–12
145 W 84th St|Less than 1 Mile Away

Global Learning Collaborative (The)

D
Public|Grades 9–12
145 W 84th St|Less than 1 Mile Away

Middle School 250 West Side Collaborative Middle School

D-
Public|Grades 6–8
735 W End Ave|Less than 1 Mile Away

P.S. 75 Emily Dickinson School

B+
Public|Grades KG–5
735 W End Ave|Less than 1 Mile Away

PS 811 Mickey Mantle School

--
Public|Grades PK–8
466 W End Ave|Less than 1 Mile Away

P.S. 9 Sarah Anderson School

A+
Public|Grades PK–5
100 W 84th St|Less than 1 Mile Away

The Studio School

--
Private|Grades PK–8
117 W 95th St|Less than 1 Mile Away

P.S. 84 Lillian Weber School

C
Public|Grades KG–5
32 W 92nd St|Less than 1 Mile Away

Middle School 243 Center School

A-
Public|Grades 5–8
100 W 84th St|Less than 1 Mile Away

Dwight School

--
Private|Grades PK–12
18 W 89th St|Less than 1 Mile Away

Trevor Day School

--
Private|Grades PK–12
1 W 88th St|Less than 1 Mile Away

Dwight School

--
Private|Grades PK–12
291 Central Park W|Less than 1 Mile Away

Calhoun School

--
Private|Grades PK–12
433 W End Ave|Less than 1 Mile Away

Columbia Grammar & Preparatory School

--
Private|Grades PK–12
5 W 93rd St|Less than 1 Mile Away

P.S. 163 Alfred E. Smith School

A
Public|Grades PK–5
163 W 97th St|Less than 1 Mile Away

Rodeph Sholom School

--
Private|Grades PK–8
10 W 84th St|Less than 1 Mile Away

Alexander Robertson School

--
Private|Grades PK–5
3 W 95th St|Less than 1 Mile Away

Basis Independent Manhattan

--
Private|Grades PK–7
795 Columbus Ave|Less than 1 Mile Away

P.S. 87 William Sherman School

A
Public|Grades KG–5
160 W 78th St|Less than 1 Mile Away

Edward a Reynolds West Side High School

D-
Public|Grades 9–12
140 W 102nd St|Less than 1 Mile Away

Middle School 247 Dual Language Middle School

A-
Public|Grades 6–8
100 W 77th St|Less than 1 Mile Away

Middle School 245 Computer School (The)

A-
Public|Grades 6–8
100 W 77th St|Less than 1 Mile Away

Anderson School (The)

A
Public|Grades KG–8
100 W 77th St|Less than 1 Mile Away

Manhattan Day School

--
Private|Grades PK–8
310 W 75th St|Less than 1 Mile Away

P.S. 145 The Bloomingdale School

C+
Public|Grades KG–5
150 W 105th St|Less than 1 Mile Away

West Preparatory Academy

C+
Public|Grades 6–8
150 W 105th St|Less than 1 Mile Away

The Parkside School

--
Private|Grades UG–UG
48 W 74th St|Less than 1 Mile Away

Robert Louis Stevenson School

--
Private|Grades 7–12
24 W 74th St|Less than 1 Mile Away

West End Day School

--
Private|Grades UG–UG
255 W 71st St|Less than 1 Mile Away

Ascension School

--
Private|Grades PK–8
220 W 108th St|Less than 1 Mile Away

Jr High School 54 Booker T Washington

B+
Public|Grades 6–8
103 W 107th St|Less than 1 Mile Away

P.S. 165 Robert E. Simon School

B-
Public|Grades PK–8
234 W 109th St|Less than 1 Mile Away

Transit

251 W 89th St enjoys proximity to 50+ public transit options throughout Manhattan. Located within a 2-mile radius, these connections enable easy commuting and dependable travel. Residents benefit from reduced reliance on private vehicles. A well-served transit location supports sustainable urban living.

103 St

0.72 miles away|14 min walk

10 AV/W 53 ST

1.84 miles away|36 min walk

10 AV/W 55 ST

1.71 miles away|33 min walk

10 AV/W 57 ST

1.64 miles away|32 min walk

110 St

1.66 miles away|32 min walk

110 St-Malcolm X Plaza

1.37 miles away|27 min walk
Next

Transit

arrow rightWhat to know about transitarrow right
Next

Description

251 W 89th St enjoys proximity to 50+ public transit options throughout Manhattan. Located within a 2-mile radius, these connections enable easy commuting and dependable travel. Residents benefit from reduced reliance on private vehicles. A well-served transit location supports sustainable urban living.

103 St

0.72 miles away|14 min walk

10 AV/W 53 ST

1.84 miles away|36 min walk

10 AV/W 55 ST

1.71 miles away|33 min walk

10 AV/W 57 ST

1.64 miles away|32 min walk

110 St

1.66 miles away|32 min walk

110 St-Malcolm X Plaza

1.37 miles away|27 min walk

116 St

1.47 miles away|29 min walk

116 St-Columbia University

1.33 miles away|26 min walk

11 AV/W 50 ST

1.97 miles away|38 min walk

11 AV/W 54 ST

1.79 miles away|35 min walk

11 AV/W 57 ST

1.65 miles away|32 min walk

11 AV/W 58 ST

1.56 miles away|30 min walk

125 St

1.87 miles away|36 min walk

12 AV/W 52 ST

1.87 miles away|36 min walk

12 AV/W 55 ST

1.73 miles away|34 min walk

1 AV/E 102 ST

1.78 miles away|35 min walk

1 AV/E 106 ST

1.86 miles away|36 min walk

1 AV/E 109 ST

1.93 miles away|38 min walk

1 AV/E 111 ST

1.99 miles away|39 min walk

1 AV/E 67 ST

1.98 miles away|38 min walk

1 AV/E 70 ST

1.9 miles away|37 min walk

1 AV/E 72 ST

1.85 miles away|36 min walk

1 AV/E 75 ST

1.79 miles away|35 min walk

1 AV/E 77 ST

1.75 miles away|34 min walk

1 AV/E 81 ST

1.7 miles away|33 min walk

1 AV/E 82 ST

1.68 miles away|33 min walk

1 AV/E 86 ST

1.65 miles away|32 min walk

1 AV/E 89 ST

1.65 miles away|32 min walk

1 AV/E 91 ST

1.65 miles away|32 min walk

1 AV/E 93 ST

1.66 miles away|32 min walk

1 AV/E 97 ST

1.7 miles away|33 min walk

1 AV/E 99 ST

1.73 miles away|34 min walk

2 AV/E 101 ST

1.61 miles away|31 min walk

2 AV/E 103 ST

1.65 miles away|32 min walk

2 AV/E 108 ST

1.76 miles away|34 min walk

2 AV/E 111 ST

1.85 miles away|36 min walk

2 AV/E 113 ST

1.91 miles away|37 min walk

2 AV/E 115 ST

1.95 miles away|38 min walk

2 AV/E 64 ST

1.98 miles away|38 min walk

2 AV/E 66 ST

1.92 miles away|37 min walk

2 AV/E 68 ST

1.86 miles away|36 min walk

2 AV/E 70 ST

1.8 miles away|35 min walk

2 AV/E 72 ST

1.74 miles away|34 min walk

2 AV/E 75 ST

1.67 miles away|33 min walk

2 AV/E 78 ST

1.6 miles away|31 min walk

2 AV/E 82 ST

1.55 miles away|30 min walk

2 AV/E 84 ST

1.53 miles away|30 min walk

2 AV/E 87 ST

1.5 miles away|29 min walk

2 AV/E 89 ST

1.5 miles away|29 min walk

2 AV/E 92 ST

1.5 miles away|29 min walk

The Neighbourhood: 251 W 89th St

Similar Buildings Nearby

Add to favoritesAdd to favorites (hover)
255 W 84th St
255 W 84th St Unit 3e, Manhattan, NY
Click to see listings
Add to favoritesAdd to favorites (hover)
258 Riverside Dr
258 Riverside Dr, Manhattan, NY
Click to see listings
Add to favoritesAdd to favorites (hover)
390 W End Ave Unit 2abc
390 W End Ave Unit 10d, Manhattan, NY
Click to see listings
Add to favoritesAdd to favorites (hover)
520 W 110th St
520 W 110th St, Manhattan, NY
Click to see listings
Add to favoritesAdd to favorites (hover)
255 W 84th St
255 W 84th St Unit 3e, Manhattan, NY
Click to see listings
Add to favoritesAdd to favorites (hover)
258 Riverside Dr
258 Riverside Dr, Manhattan, NY
Click to see listings
Add to favoritesAdd to favorites (hover)
390 W End Ave Unit 2abc
390 W End Ave Unit 10d, Manhattan, NY
Click to see listings
View All Similar Buildings

251 W 89th St Demographics

Age Demographics

0–14 Years

13.98%

15–29 Years

16.31%

30–44 Years

23.78%

45–59 Years

19%

60+ Years

26.92%

Commute

53.28%

Transit

10.24%

Walk

7.08%

Drive

2.98%

Bike

Housing Ownership

35.53%

Owner Occupied

64.47%

Rental Units

Household Types

Single Family
20.37%
Multi Family
3.52%
Single Person
45%
Multi Person
55%

Average Income

Household:$12,050,336.91 /yr

Individual:$11,089,085.8 /yr

Education

Bachelors Degree32%
High School College7.9%
Diploma2.75%
Post Graduate42.61%
Others14.75%
Next

Education

Diploma2.75%
Post Graduate42.61%
Others14.75%
Get the HelloCondo Newsletter
Real-estate tips, insights, and market reports in your inbox.
Newsletter
  1. Home
  2. /New York, NY
  3. /
    251 W 89th St
Nearby Cities
Glen Oaks
Buildings
201 W 89th St
203 W 90th St
205 W 89th St Unit Ph6/7
210 W 90th St
215 W 88th St
215 W 90th St
250 W 88th St
250 W 89th St
250 W 90th St
251 W 89th St
251 W 91st St
269 W 87th St
565 W End Ave
588 W End Ave
590 W End Ave
595 W End Ave
599 W End Ave
600 W End Ave
601 W End Ave
607 W End Ave
Neighborhoods
Battery Park CityCentral HarlemCentral Park
East VillageKips BayKoreatownLittle ItalyLower East SideManhattanvilleMurray HillNolitaNoMadPeter Cooper VillageRandalls and Wards IslandSoHoThe BoweryTheater DistrictTriBeCaTwo BridgesUpper East Side
ZIP Codes
100021000510019
1002210025100301003810040100441006510075101051011110121101531016710169101721017610177
Community
104 Bedford Street115 Cabrini Boulevard130 Jane Street
14 Bogardus Place143-153 Bennett Avenue145 West 12th Street173 Riverside Drive1922 McGraw Avenue226 East 12th Street30 West 60th Street3015-3017 Riverdale Avenue308 West 97th Street32-23 90th Street33-15 81st Street33-52 81st Street34-30 78th Street35-11 85th Street350 West 56th Street39 Gramercy Park North43-33 46th Street
HelloCondo Logo
HelloCondo Logo
HelloCondo Is The #1 Condo Search Platform And Real Estate Recommendation Engine. Search, Find And Buy The Perfect Condo And Get Matched With The Best Agents. Finding A Condo Has Never Been So Easy.

HelloCondo is a division of HelloCasa, LLC

FacebookIconInstagramIconXIconRedditIcon

HelloCondo

Find A RealtorTerms of UsePrivacy PolicyCalifornia Privacy NoticeAccessibility PolicyCCPA Notice on CollectionDMCABrowseNYS Standard Operating ProcedureNYS Fair Housing Notice

Contact

LocationIcon
300 Galleria Pkwy SE, Suite 1500,
Atlanta, GA 30339
PhoneICon
(855) 625-0319
EmailIConhello@hellocondo.com
Contact Us

For Sale

Condos for saleTownhomes for sale
AgentIcon
LocationIcon

Century21, Awaye Realty

Arlene Waye

526 Court Street

Brooklyn, NY 11231

PhoneICon(718) 488-0800
EmailIConawaye@c21awayerealty.com
© HelloCondo 2026. All Rights Reserved.