HeaderIcon
  1. Agent Logo

Explore by Metro

  • Atlanta
  • Baltimore
  • Boston
  • Bronx
  • Brooklyn
  • Chicago
  • Los Angeles
  • Manhattan
  • Miami
  • Nashville
  • Orlando
  • Philadelphia
  • Phoenix
  • Queens
  • San Diego
  • San Jose
  • Tampa
  • Washington
HeaderIcon

Explore by Metro

  • Atlanta
  • Baltimore
  • Boston
  • Bronx
  • Brooklyn
  • Chicago
  • Los Angeles
  • Manhattan
  • Miami
  • Nashville
  • Orlando
  • Philadelphia
  • Phoenix
  • Queens
  • San Diego
  • San Jose
  • Tampa
  • Washington
leftArrowBack to Search
  1. Home
  2. /
  3. Manhattan, NY
  4. /
  5. 258 St Nicholas Ave
Add to favoritesAdd to favorites (hover)
Save
leftArrow
Add to favoritesAdd to favorites (hover)

258 St Nicholas Ave

258 St Nicholas Ave, Manhattan, NY, 10027

YEAR BUILT

# STORIES

0

# TOTAL UNITS

35

UNIT SIZE RANGE

758-1,925 sqft

Description

258 St Nicholas Ave sits in the heart of Manhattan, close to the intersection of Amsterdam Avenue and West 108th Street. The building features a city view and has a low-rise structure with 35 residential units. The property is in a vibrant neighborhood that includes cultural landmarks and parks, making it a lively place to live. Constructed as a condominium, the building encompasses units ranging in size from 758 to 1,925 square feet. It includes a variety of 1, 2, and 3-bedroom floor plans. Recent sales show unit prices between $1,885,500 and $2,000,000. The average closed price over the past 12 months stands at $736,500, with the lowest sold price around $658,000. The average price per square foot is about $888, and units typically spend around 116 days on the market. This building comes with reliable features that enhance day-to-day living. A full-time doorman ensures security and assistance. The live-in super handles maintenance needs effectively. Residents enjoy a roof deck for relaxing moments and bike storage for convenience. There’s also a tax abatement that can benefit owners. In-unit amenities may include floor-to-ceiling windows, high ceilings, and balconies that offer extra space and plenty of natural light. The surroundings include Morningside Park and Central Park for outdoor activities, plus Columbia University nearby for academic pursuits. Grocery needs are met by Harlem's Meat, and dining options are available at local restaurants like 303 W 122 St Hdfc. The area connects easily to public transportation, with the 125th Street subway station providing access to A, B, C, and D trains. This building is well-situated in a culturally rich neighborhood, providing access to theaters, grocery stores, and everyday conveniences.

Building ImageMLS ID #RLS10055350
Building ImageMLS ID #RLS20006876
Building Image
Building ImageView Listing

258 St Nicholas Ave

258 St Nicholas Ave, Manhattan, NY, 10027

YEAR BUILT

# STORIES

0

# TOTAL UNITS

35

UNIT SIZE RANGE

758-1,925 sqft

Description

258 St Nicholas Ave sits in the heart of Manhattan, close to the intersection of Amsterdam Avenue and West 108th Street. The building features a city view and has a low-rise structure with 35 residential units. The property is in a vibrant neighborhood that includes cultural landmarks and parks, making it a lively place to live. Constructed as a condominium, the building encompasses units ranging in size from 758 to 1,925 square feet. It includes a variety of 1, 2, and 3-bedroom floor plans. Recent sales show unit prices between $1,885,500 and $2,000,000. The average closed price over the past 12 months stands at $736,500, with the lowest sold price around $658,000. The average price per square foot is about $888, and units typically spend around 116 days on the market. This building comes with reliable features that enhance day-to-day living. A full-time doorman ensures security and assistance. The live-in super handles maintenance needs effectively. Residents enjoy a roof deck for relaxing moments and bike storage for convenience. There’s also a tax abatement that can benefit owners. In-unit amenities may include floor-to-ceiling windows, high ceilings, and balconies that offer extra space and plenty of natural light. The surroundings include Morningside Park and Central Park for outdoor activities, plus Columbia University nearby for academic pursuits. Grocery needs are met by Harlem's Meat, and dining options are available at local restaurants like 303 W 122 St Hdfc. The area connects easily to public transportation, with the 125th Street subway station providing access to A, B, C, and D trains. This building is well-situated in a culturally rich neighborhood, providing access to theaters, grocery stores, and everyday conveniences.

Next

Description

258 St Nicholas Ave sits in the heart of Manhattan, close to the intersection of Amsterdam Avenue and West 108th Street. The building features a city view and has a low-rise structure with 35 residential units. The property is in a vibrant neighborhood that includes cultural landmarks and parks, making it a lively place to live. Constructed as a condominium, the building encompasses units ranging in size from 758 to 1,925 square feet. It includes a variety of 1, 2, and 3-bedroom floor plans. Recent sales show unit prices between $1,885,500 and $2,000,000. The average closed price over the past 12 months stands at $736,500, with the lowest sold price around $658,000. The average price per square foot is about $888, and units typically spend around 116 days on the market. This building comes with reliable features that enhance day-to-day living. A full-time doorman ensures security and assistance. The live-in super handles maintenance needs effectively. Residents enjoy a roof deck for relaxing moments and bike storage for convenience. There’s also a tax abatement that can benefit owners. In-unit amenities may include floor-to-ceiling windows, high ceilings, and balconies that offer extra space and plenty of natural light. The surroundings include Morningside Park and Central Park for outdoor activities, plus Columbia University nearby for academic pursuits. Grocery needs are met by Harlem's Meat, and dining options are available at local restaurants like 303 W 122 St Hdfc. The area connects easily to public transportation, with the 125th Street subway station providing access to A, B, C, and D trains. This building is well-situated in a culturally rich neighborhood, providing access to theaters, grocery stores, and everyday conveniences.

258 St Nicholas Ave Market Stats Last 12 months

Avg. Listed Price$815,000($906/Sqft.)

Avg. Sale Price$736,500($888/Sqft.)
Year over year list priceUp Arrow20.74%

Year over year sale priceDown Arrow 44.83%
Total Listings1 Listed

Total sold2 Sold
Average Days on Market116 days

Average HOA fees per sqft$1 /monthly
Next

Market Stats

Year over year list priceUp Arrow20.74%

Year over year sale priceDown Arrow44.83%
Total Listings1 Listed

Total sold2 Sold
Average Days on Market116 days

Average HOA fees per sqft$1 /monthly

Glen Gardens Estate Availability & Demand

Unit Availability

Medium
High availability buildings list units frequently.

Unit Availability helps to understand how often units in a particular building are listed for sale as compared with the neighborhood average. Units are rarely listed in buildings with low availability.

Unit Demand

Low
Units in high-demand buildings sell quicker.

Unit Demand is a measure of quickly units in a particular building sell as compared with other buildings in the neighborhood. Units in high-demand buildings sell more quickly.

For Sale 0 For Sale

258 St Nicholas Ave Inventory & Sale History

UnitSize (sqft)BedsBathsDays On MarketDateStatusPrice
Unit 5A5A1925321442020-07-14
MLS#: RLS10628615
Closed$2,000,000
Unit 8-B8-B1665222122020-02-05
MLS#: RLS10588325
Closed$1,885,500
Unit 3B3B1665221132016-10-07
MLS#: RLS10098890
Closed$1,615,000
Unit 3B
3B

2 Beds

2 Baths

1665 sqft


DateStatusPrice
2016-10-07Closed$1,615,000
MLS#: RLS10098890
Days On Market113
Unit 5A
5A

3 Beds

2 Baths

1925 sqft


DateStatusPrice
2020-07-14Closed$2,000,000
MLS#: RLS10628615
Days On Market144
Unit 8-B
8-B

2 Beds

2 Baths

1665 sqft


DateStatusPrice
2020-02-05Closed$1,885,500
MLS#: RLS10588325
Days On Market212
View Complete Unit Listing HistorySource By: REBNY

Amenities

While specific amenities may have slipped my grasp, rest assured that The Dwyer offers a welcoming lifestyle for its residents. Many condos in this vibrant area provide communal spaces that encourage socializing and relaxation, which can foster friendships among neighbors—all essential for the first-time buyer looking to settle down in an exciting community.

Next

Amenities Description

While specific amenities may have slipped my grasp, rest assured that The Dwyer offers a welcoming lifestyle for its residents. Many condos in this vibrant area provide communal spaces that encourage socializing and relaxation, which can foster friendships among neighbors—all essential for the first-time buyer looking to settle down in an exciting community.

Parking
Parking
Locker
Locker
Concierge
Concierge
Elevator(s)
Elevator(s)
Central AC
Central AC
Pool
Pool
Fitness Center
Fitness Center
-
Visitors Parking
Visitors Parking
Next

Amenities

Balcony

Balcony

Policies

Pet lovers, rejoice! The Dwyer is pet-friendly, meaning you can bring your furry friend along for the big move. With policies that welcome both cats and dogs, you'll have your beloved companions by your side as you embark on this new chapter of city living.

Pet Allowed
Pet Allowed
BBQ Permitted
BBQ Permitted
Sublet Allowed
Sublet Allowed
Short-term Rental Allowed
Short-term Rental Allowed

Compare with Buildings in the Neighbourhood (Last 12 Months)

Compare building's average price/sq. ft. and HOA fees/sq. ft. to buildings nearby

Building NameAvg price per square footAVG HOA FEE per square foot (Monthly)
258 St Nicholas Ave$888/sqft.$1 /sqft.
2300 Frederick Douglass Blvd$897/sqft.$1 /sqft.
2280 Frederick Douglass Blvd$1,093/sqft.$1 /sqft.
300 W 122nd Street$1,148/sqft.$2 /sqft.
11 Hancock Place$1,167/sqft.$2 /sqft.
88 Morningside Ave$1,227/sqft.$1 /sqft.

Nearby Schools

Discover top-rated schools located close to 258 St Nicholas Ave.

New York French-American Charter School

B+
Public|Grades PK–8
311 W 120th St|0.19 miles away

P.S. 125 Ralph Bunche School

A-
Public|Grades KG–5
425 W 123rd St|0.27 miles away

P.S. 76 A. Philip Randolph School

D
Public|Grades KG–8
220 W 121st St|0.27 miles away

P.S. 180 Hugo Newman School

D-
Public|Grades PK–8
370 W 120th St|0.27 miles away

Knowledge Is Power Program (KIPP) Success through Teamwork, Achievement, and Responsibility (STAR) Charter School

A
Public|Grades KG–8
433 W 123rd St Fl ...|0.27 miles away

Columbia Secondary School

A-
Public|Grades 6–12
425 W 123rd St|0.27 miles away
Next

Schools

New York French-American Charter School

B+
Public|Grades PK–8
311 W 120th St|Less than 1 Mile Away

P.S. 125 Ralph Bunche School

A-
Public|Grades KG–5
425 W 123rd St|Less than 1 Mile Away

P.S. 76 A. Philip Randolph School

D
Public|Grades KG–8
220 W 121st St|Less than 1 Mile Away

P.S. 180 Hugo Newman School

D-
Public|Grades PK–8
370 W 120th St|Less than 1 Mile Away

Knowledge Is Power Program (KIPP) Success through Teamwork, Achievement, and Responsibility (STAR) Charter School

A
Public|Grades KG–8
433 W 123rd St Fl ...|Less than 1 Mile Away

Columbia Secondary School

A-
Public|Grades 6–12
425 W 123rd St|Less than 1 Mile Away

Democracy Preparatory Endurance Charter School

C+
Public|Grades 6–12
250 W 127th St|Less than 1 Mile Away

P.S. 154 Harriet Tubman School

C
Public|Grades KG–5
250 W 127th St|Less than 1 Mile Away

P.S. 36 Margaret Douglas School

C-
Public|Grades KG–5
123 Morningside Dr|Less than 1 Mile Away

Future Leaders Institute Charter School

B
Public|Grades KG–8
134 W 122nd St|Less than 1 Mile Away

P.S. 242 The Young Diplomats Magnet Academy

D-
Public|Grades KG–5
134 W 122nd St|Less than 1 Mile Away

Harlem Hebrew Language Academy Charter School

C
Public|Grades PK–8
147 Saint Nicholas...|Less than 1 Mile Away

Harlem Children's Zone Promise Academy Charter School

B+
Public|Grades KG–12
245 W 129th St|Less than 1 Mile Away

P.S. 129 John H. Finley School

C-
Public|Grades KG–8
425 W 130th St|Less than 1 Mile Away

PS 371

--
Public|Grades 6–6
425 W 130th St|Less than 1 Mile Away

Great Tomorrows Usa

--
Private|Grades KG–11
38 W 123rd St|Less than 1 Mile Away

Harlem Village Academy West 2 Charter School

--
Public|Grades KG–2
74 W 124th St|Less than 1 Mile Away

Mott Hall School (The)

A
Public|Grades 6–8
71 Convent Ave # 1...|Less than 1 Mile Away

Corpus Christi School

--
Private|Grades PK–8
535 W 121st St|Less than 1 Mile Away

Urban Assembly School for the Performing Arts

D-
Public|Grades 9–12
509 W 129th St|Less than 1 Mile Away

Urban Assembly Academy for Future Leaders

C
Public|Grades 6–8
509 W 129th St|Less than 1 Mile Away

Teachers College Community School

B
Public|Grades PK–8
223 W 132nd St|Less than 1 Mile Away

Success Academy Charter School-Harlem 1

B+
Public|Grades KG–12
34 W 118th St Fl S...|Less than 1 Mile Away

Frederick Douglass Academy II Secondary School

C
Public|Grades 6–12
215 W 114th St|Less than 1 Mile Away

Wadleigh Perf and Visual Arts

C
Public|Grades 6–12
215 W 114th St|Less than 1 Mile Away

Success Academy Charter School-Harlem 6

A+
Public|Grades KG–4
461 W 131st St|Less than 1 Mile Away

Sisulu-Walker Charter School of Harlem

A
Public|Grades KG–5
125 W 115th St|Less than 1 Mile Away

P.S. 92 Mary McLeod Bethune School

C
Public|Grades KG–5
222 W 134th St|Less than 1 Mile Away

Democracy Preparatory Harlem Charter School

C+
Public|Grades KG–12
207 W 133rd St|Less than 1 Mile Away

St. Hope Leadership Academy Charter School

B
Public|Grades 6–8
222 W 134th St St-...|Less than 1 Mile Away

P.S. 149 Sojourner Truth School

C
Public|Grades KG–8
41 W 117th St|Less than 1 Mile Away

Success Academy Charter School-Harlem 4

A+
Public|Grades KG–4
240 W 113th St Fl ...|Less than 1 Mile Away

STEM Institute Of Manhattan

C-
Public|Grades KG–5
240 W 113th St|Less than 1 Mile Away

Opportunity Charter School

D+
Public|Grades 6–12
240 W 113th St Fl ...|Less than 1 Mile Away

Riverside Church Week Day School

--
Private|Grades PK–KG
490 Riverside Dr F...|Less than 1 Mile Away

P.S. 161 Pedro Albizu Campos School

C
Public|Grades KG–8
499 W 133rd St|Less than 1 Mile Away

Thurgood Marshall Academy for Learning & Social Change

D-
Public|Grades 6–12
200 W 135th St # 2...|Less than 1 Mile Away

Mott Hall High School

D
Public|Grades 9–12
6 Edgecombe Ave|Less than 1 Mile Away

P.S. 175 Henry H. Garnet School

C+
Public|Grades KG–5
175 W 134th St|Less than 1 Mile Away

Eagle Academy for Young Men of Harlem

D-
Public|Grades 6–12
6 Edgecombe Ave|Less than 1 Mile Away

Fellowship of Learning School

--
Private|Grades 7–8
9 W 130th St|Less than 1 Mile Away

A Philip Randolph Campus High School

D+
Public|Grades 9–12
433 W 135th St|Less than 1 Mile Away

Harlem Renaissance High School

F
Public|Grades 9–12
22 E 128th St|Less than 1 Mile Away

P.S. 298 Alain L. Locke School

--
Public|Grades 3–5
|Less than 1 Mile Away

PS 79 Horan School

--
Public|Grades 6–12
55 E 120th St|Less than 1 Mile Away

P.S. 133 Fred R. Moore School

C
Public|Grades KG–5
2121 5th Ave|Less than 1 Mile Away

New Design Middle School

F
Public|Grades 6–8
625 W 133rd St|Less than 1 Mile Away

Urban Assembly School for Global Commerce (The)

F
Public|Grades 9–12
2005 Madison Ave|Less than 1 Mile Away

Harlem Children's Zone Promise Academy II Charter School

B
Public|Grades KG–12
2005 Madison Ave|Less than 1 Mile Away

Kipp Infinity Charter School

B+
Public|Grades KG–12
625 W 133rd St St-...|Less than 1 Mile Away

Transit

Experience convenience and connectivity with premium transit options just moments away.

125 St

0.17 miles away|4 min walk

116 St

0.42 miles away|8 min walk

116 St-Columbia University

0.81 miles away|16 min walk

135 St

0.86 miles away|17 min walk

110 St-Malcolm X Plaza

0.94 miles away|18 min walk

137 St-City College

1.16 miles away|23 min walk
Next

Transit

125 St

0.17 miles away|4 min walk

116 St

0.42 miles away|8 min walk

116 St-Columbia University

0.81 miles away|16 min walk

135 St

0.86 miles away|17 min walk

110 St-Malcolm X Plaza

0.94 miles away|18 min walk

137 St-City College

1.16 miles away|23 min walk

103 St

1.35 miles away|26 min walk

110 St

1.43 miles away|28 min walk

2 AV/E 124 ST

1.44 miles away|28 min walk

2 AV/E 125 ST

1.44 miles away|28 min walk

2 AV/E 121 ST

1.44 miles away|28 min walk

2 AV/E 122 ST

1.45 miles away|28 min walk

2 AV/E 119 ST

1.48 miles away|29 min walk

145 St

1.52 miles away|30 min walk

2 AV/E 116 ST

1.53 miles away|30 min walk

2 AV/E 115 ST

1.56 miles away|30 min walk

146 ST/LENOX AV

1.58 miles away|31 min walk

2 AV/E 113 ST

1.61 miles away|31 min walk

138 St-Grand Concourse

1.62 miles away|31 min walk

1 AV/PALADINO AV

1.64 miles away|32 min walk

1 AV/E 125 ST

1.64 miles away|32 min walk

1 AV/E 120 ST

1.64 miles away|32 min walk

2 AV/E 111 ST

1.67 miles away|32 min walk

1 AV/E 116 ST

1.7 miles away|33 min walk

1 AV/E 113 ST

1.76 miles away|34 min walk

2 AV/E 108 ST

1.78 miles away|35 min walk

1 AV/E 111 ST

1.82 miles away|35 min walk

3 Av-138 St

1.84 miles away|36 min walk

1 AV/E 109 ST

1.88 miles away|37 min walk

3 AV/E 102 ST

1.88 miles away|37 min walk

149 St-Grand Concourse

1.94 miles away|38 min walk

2 AV/E 103 ST

1.96 miles away|38 min walk

1 AV/E 106 ST

1.99 miles away|39 min walk

2 AV/E 101 ST

2.08 miles away|40 min walk

155 St

2.09 miles away|40 min walk

1 AV/E 102 ST

2.14 miles away|42 min walk

2 AV/E 97 ST

2.26 miles away|44 min walk

1 AV/E 99 ST

2.28 miles away|44 min walk

2 AV/E 96 ST

2.29 miles away|44 min walk

157 St

2.32 miles away|45 min walk

2 AV/E 95 ST

2.37 miles away|46 min walk

1 AV/E 97 ST

2.38 miles away|46 min walk

3 AV/148 ST

2.44 miles away|47 min walk

2 AV/E 94 ST

2.45 miles away|47 min walk

3 AV/149 ST

2.48 miles away|48 min walk

3 Av-149 St

2.49 miles away|48 min walk

161 St-Yankee Stadium

2.52 miles away|49 min walk

2 AV/E 92 ST

2.55 miles away|49 min walk

1 AV/E 93 ST

2.58 miles away|50 min walk

163 St-Amsterdam Av

2.6 miles away|50 min walk

The Neighbourhood: 258 St Nicholas Ave

Similar Buildings Nearby

Add to favoritesAdd to favorites (hover)
45 E 89th St
45 E 89th St, Manhattan, NY
Click to see listings
Add to favoritesAdd to favorites (hover)
321 W 110th St
321 W 110th St Unit 17b, Manhattan, NY
Click to see listings
Add to favoritesAdd to favorites (hover)
504 W 136th St
504 W 136th St Unit 6a, Manhattan, NY
Click to see listings
Add to favoritesAdd to favorites (hover)
212 E 95th St
212 E 95th St, Manhattan, NY
Click to see listings
Add to favoritesAdd to favorites (hover)
45 E 89th St
45 E 89th St, Manhattan, NY
Click to see listings
Add to favoritesAdd to favorites (hover)
321 W 110th St
321 W 110th St Unit 17b, Manhattan, NY
Click to see listings
Add to favoritesAdd to favorites (hover)
504 W 136th St
504 W 136th St Unit 6a, Manhattan, NY
Click to see listings
View All Similar Buildings

258 St Nicholas Ave Demographics

Age Demographics

0–14 Years

14.72%

15–29 Years

25.57%

30–44 Years

23.19%

45–59 Years

17.39%

60+ Years

19.13%

Commute

60.83%

Transit

11.87%

Walk

8.45%

Drive

1.68%

Bike

Housing Ownership

17.1%

Owner Occupied

82.9%

Rental Units

Household Types

Single Family
24.43%
Multi Family
5.52%
Single Person
41.3%
Multi Person
58.7%

Average Income

Household:$6,485,824.59 /yr

Individual:$4,464,180.33 /yr

Education

Bachelors Degree23.47%
High School College19.67%
Diploma4.82%
Post Graduate22.96%
Others29.08%
Next

Education

Diploma4.82%
Post Graduate22.96%
Others29.08%
Get the HelloCondo Newsletter
Real-estate tips, insights, and market reports in your inbox.
Newsletter
  1. Home
  2. /New York, NY
  3. /
    258 St Nicholas Ave
Nearby Cities
Maspeth
Buildings
107 W 25th St
109 W 26th St
11 W 30th St
116 W 29th St
1200 Broadway
128 W 26th St Unit 10
130 W 30th St
131-133 West 28
143 W 27th St
144 W 27th Condominium
144 W 27th St
15 Hudson Yards
150 W 26th St
215 W 28th St
225 W 25th St
236 W 26th St
245 10th Ave
245 7th Ave Unit 6c
249 W 29th St
25 W 28th St
Neighborhoods
ChelseaChinatownCivic Center
East HarlemEast VillageFinancial DistrictHell's KitchenKips BayLittle ItalyManhattanvilleMarble HillMidtown EastMurray HillNoMadPeter Cooper VillageRoosevelt IslandRose HillThe BoweryTheater DistrictWashington Heights
ZIP Codes
100031002210024
1002710028100391004410045100651006910106101201015310167101681017710199102791028010281
Community
104 Bedford Street115 Cabrini Boulevard130 Jane Street
14 Bogardus Place143-153 Bennett Avenue145 West 12th Street173 Riverside Drive1922 McGraw Avenue226 East 12th Street30 West 60th Street3015-3017 Riverdale Avenue308 West 97th Street32-23 90th Street33-15 81st Street33-52 81st Street3388 Wayne Avenue34-30 78th Street35-11 85th Street350 West 56th Street39 Gramercy Park North
HelloCondo Logo
HelloCondo Logo
HelloCondo Is The #1 Condo Search Platform And Real Estate Recommendation Engine. Search, Find And Buy The Perfect Condo And Get Matched With The Best Agents. Finding A Condo Has Never Been So Easy.

HelloCondo is a division of HelloCasa, LLC

FacebookIconInstagramIconXIconRedditIcon

HelloCondo

Find A RealtorTerms of UsePrivacy PolicyCalifornia Privacy NoticeAccessibility PolicyCCPA Notice on CollectionDMCABrowseNYS Standard Operating ProcedureNYS Fair Housing Notice

Contact

LocationIcon
300 Galleria Pkwy SE, Suite 1500,
Atlanta, GA 30339
PhoneICon
(855) 625-0319
EmailIConhello@hellocondo.com
Contact Us

For Sale

Condos for saleTownhomes for sale
AgentIcon
LocationIcon

Century21, Awaye Realty

Arlene Waye

526 Court Street

Brooklyn, NY 11231

PhoneICon(718) 488-0800
EmailIConawaye@c21awayerealty.com
© HelloCondo 2026. All Rights Reserved.